Please Help - I need to trim (Full Version)

All Forums >> [General] >> Writers Roundtable



Message


Locke -> Please Help - I need to trim (5/29/2008 2:55:17 PM)

So I thought I'd finally enter something into the FaithWriters writing contest. I wrote the piece (located below), "Captivo" on the topic "The Family House." As you can tell, I was less than fond of the topic, so I did my best to nod to it while completely ignoring it. We'll see how they take that. They likely won't like that, but oh well.

Anyway, I need to get this baby under 750 words. It's currently at 960. Being my work, it pains me to delete anything. Could anyone give some some suggestions on things that I might be able to cut out? I'll discuss that at the end. Also, please let me know your opinions on this work as well! Thanks.




"Captivo"
By Michael N Lovdal

Captivo struggled against the pull of his straightjacket in desperation.
"No!" he screamed, "you can't make me one of you!" The sound of diesel and the shaking room told him that he was in some kind of truck. There were two people before him, he saw. They were dressed and groomed identically, with short cropped white hair and charcoal-black suits that were wired throughout. Tiny lights blinked on their collars.
"Refrain from motion, young one," warned the person on the left. Captivo searched the people's faces for signs of gender, but all he could identify was that these people were indeed human: their eyes were cold and lifeless, their noses small and fragile; their teeth were white as their hair, and twice as shiny; their lips were glossed and slender, and their cheekbones were recessed beyond recondition.

The boy did not cease his fight. One of his captors grabbed him by the hair and forced his head down, bashing his nose into his knee. He felt a painful sting in the back of his neck, and the sound of a air-compressor gun going off behind him. The hand released and he straightened up in pain. A tear streaked down his face as he realized that sitting up made his neck hurt even worse. He may have even felt liquid behind his neck. The people's faces remained expressionless, apathetic.
"What did you do to me?" he asked in horror.
"You have been nerve-stapled, child. Remain still, or the device will send a hundred volts of electricity down your spine." He was desperate to escape, but Captivo had no desire to feel the shock from this device. The floor shook violently under them as the truck rounded a sharp turn. The momentum slammed Captivo into the wall. True to his captor's word, the sudden jerk of his body activated the nerve-staple and a quick shock ran down his back. Despite the pain this caused, he was too busy being pulled out of the now-parked vehicle to fully appreciate his plight.

The harsh sunlight assaulted his eyes as he emerged from the truck. He was being pulled from handles on his straight-jacket. A girl screamed in the distance as she was pulled from two adults, likely her parents. The parents were held back by force, by two captors that looked much the same as Captivo's. Before him rose a massive skyscraper that was easily thirty stories tall. The windows were all tinted black, harshly contrasting with the calming blue sky. He gave up fighting quickly, finding compliance to be a much less painful scenario. The lobby of the building was a metallic-silver color, with glossy-black low-lights. A plainly written sign on the wall identified this building as "The Family Home; Reeducation Center." Tiny red-tinted lights guided their way as they approached and entered the elevator, an intimidatingly large portal into an even deeper black place. The elevator screeched as it hurled upwards. There was no floor indicator, so Captivo could only imagine how many floors they were going up. Or down. The thought of going down frightened him even more. Yes - they were definitely going down!

The elevator stopped after a few minutes and the door opened. Hundreds of brilliant lights poured in from the room before him, blinding him for a few moments. He was forced ahead into the room, which he saw was in fact a massive gymnasium of some description. Children were playing in groups and in lines and... he was surprised not to hear any laughter. Not a single child spoke, nor were any children running about. They merely sat quietly in a circle. Another group seemed to be going to a side room in single file. No adults led them, they just seemed to know where to go on their own. At the far end of the gymnasium there was another massive doorway which they made their way through. They passed through hall after hall, room after room. Captivo saw a room with white dogs, all with a single black spot on their foreheads. He saw a room of artists - they all drew the same rainbow on the same large-sized canvases. He wanted to protest with them, wanted to just tell them that there was so much more that they could be doing with their talents. But alas, he was in no position to do anything.

Captivo was finally lead into a small, empty room. He sat down by himself on the floor by the back wall, and just stared up at his two captors. One captor almost looked teary-eyed. When emotion crossed this person's face, he saw slightly feminine characteristics shine through this guise of generic gender.
"Please help me," pleaded the boy. He knew that this woman's heart had been touched. There was a soul in there.
"You can't fight it," responded the woman, "no one can. I tried, but I couldn't. No one can," she repeated. The other captor began to close the gated door.
"You'll be released into The Society once you've undergone the reeducation process." Captivo leapt up to his feet and slammed his shoulders in the door, but it was already locked shut.
"I'll never surrender! I'll never surrender! My spirit will not be broken!" He stood there crying, recovering from the pain of another shock from his nerve-staple. He collapsed on the ground, hopeless. As defiant as his proclamation had been, his fighting spirit truly had been crushed - until he heard a scream in the room beside him. He heard a steel door close and lock, and then the strong voice of a girl.
""I'll never surrender! I'll never be broken!"

© 2008 Mike Lovdal.




So basically anything that talks about The Reeducation Center being conformist is important to keep in. The references to the female hostage are also essential, as is the final exchange with the female captor. Lastly, the paragraphs have to start with those words. They were designed that way on purpose - first and last start with his name, the middle three with the world's most generic word - "the." Other than that, i'm not too picky.

Let me know. Thanks!




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/29/2008 3:11:43 PM)

I was just thinking - if people prefer this version to a shorter version, I may enter a shorter version, but keep this one on my FW page. We shall see...




Elena1030 -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 10:20:15 AM)

Can't do it now, but I can do some editing for you a little later today. Would that still get you in by the deadline?




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 10:21:46 AM)

Well... 60 views and no comments. Is this story too edgy for this site? I thought about dumbing it down, considering that Christian readers are often hypersensitive to negative imagery, but it just took the teeth out of the piece.

Anyway, if I don't receive any feedback today, i'm just going to chop it up myself and be done with it.

Thanks to anyone who would help but doesn't have time - i'm that person often, so I certainly understand.




Elena1030 -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 10:25:16 AM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Locke

Well... 60 views and no comments. Is this story too edgy for this site? I thought about dumbing it down, considering that Christian readers are often hypersensitive to negative imagery, but it just took the teeth out of the piece.

Anyway, if I don't receive any feedback today, i'm just going to chop it up myself and be done with it.

Thanks to anyone who would help but doesn't have time - i'm that person often, so I certainly understand.


I haven't read it, so I cannot comment on what I think of your story. I was going to read it and edit at the same time. And by editing, I mean on the micro level --- tighten the wording --- rather than macro revision of key elements.

I can return at lunchtime (11:00 a.m. Central US) and do this. Can ya wait 1.5 hours? [;)]




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 10:27:41 AM)

That would be amazing - thank you! I just want to get it entered right away so I can post it and move on.




Elena1030 -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 12:53:58 PM)

I've gotten it down to 806 words just by tightening the writing. So... now you need to figure out what can be cut out. Do you need the descriptions of the building? See how many adjectives and adverbs you can cut out. See if you can replace some of the verb phrases with single and stronger verbs.


Here's my edited version (806 words):

"Captivo"
By Michael N. Lovdal

Captivo struggled against the pull of his straightjacket in desperation. "No!" he screamed. "You can't make me one of you!" The sounds and sensations revealed he was in some kind of truck. Two people stood before him, dressed and groomed identically, with cropped white hair and charcoal-black suits that were wired throughout. Tiny lights blinked on their collars.

"Refrain from motion, young one," one warned.

Captivo searched the faces for signs of gender, but all he could identify was that they indeed were human. The eyes were cold and lifeless; noses, small and fragile; teeth, white as the hair and twice as shiny. The slender lips were glossed; their cheekbones, recessed beyond recognition.

The boy kept fighting. One captor grabbed him by the hair and forced his head down, bashing his nose into his knee. Captivo felt a painful sting in the back of his neck. He heard an a air-compressor gun go off behind him. The hand released and he straightened up in pain. A tear streaked down his face: sitting up made his neck hurt even worse. Was that liquid behind his neck? The two faces remained expressionless.

"What did you do to me?" he asked in horror.

"You have been nerve-stapled, child. Remain still, or the device will send a hundred volts of electricity down your spine."

He was desperate to escape, but Captivo had no desire to feel the electric shock. The floor shook violently under them as the truck rounded a sharp turn. The momentum slammed Captivo into the wall. The sudden jerk of his body activated the nerve-staple, and a quick shock ran down his back. Despite the pain, his attention was diverted by being pulled out of the now-parked vehicle. Captivo had yet to fully appreciate his plight.

Harsh sunlight assaulted his eyes as he emerged from the truck. Someone pulled the handles on his straight-jacket. A girl screamed in the distance as she was pulled away from two adults, likely her parents. Two captors who looked similar to Captivo’s held the parents back.

A massive skyscraper, easily thirty stories tall, rose before Captivo. The black-tinted windows contrasted harshly against the calming blue sky. He quickly gave up fighting: compliance was less painful.

The building’s lobby was metallic silver with glossy-black low-lights. A plainly written sign read "The Family Home; Reeducation Center." Tiny red-tinted lights guided the way as they approached and entered the elevator, an intimidating large portal into an even deeper black place. The elevator screeched as it hurled upwards. Nothing indicated the floors, so Captivo could only imagine how many stories they were going up. Or down. Going down frightened him even more. Wait! Yes - they were definitely going down!

The elevator stopped after a few minutes. The door opened. Hundreds of brilliant lights poured in from the room before him, blinding him for a few moments. He was forced ahead into the room, which was a massive gymnasium. Children were playing in groups and in lines—but no laughter. Not a single child spoke, nor were any children running about. They merely sat quietly in a circle. Another group seemed to be going to a side room in single file. No adults led them; they just seemed to know where to go.

At the far end of the gymnasium another doorway opened. They made their way through. They passed through hall after hall, room after room. Captivo saw a room with white dogs, a single black spot on every forehead. He saw a room of artists, all drawing the same rainbow on the same large-size canvases. He wanted to protest, to scream that they could do so much more with their talents. But alas, he could do nothing.

Captivo was led into a small, empty room. He sat down on the floor by the back wall and stared at his two captors. One captor almost looked teary-eyed. When emotion crossed the face, he saw slightly feminine characteristics shine through the guise of generic gender.

"Please help me," pleaded the boy. He knew this woman's heart had been touched. A soul was in there.

"You can't fight it," she said. “No one can. I tried, but I couldn't. No one can.”

The other captor closed the gated door. "You'll be released into The Society once you've undergone the reeducation process."

Captivo leapt to his feet and slammed his shoulders in the door, but it was already locked shut. "I'll never surrender! I'll never surrender! My spirit will not be broken!" He stood there crying, recovering from the pain of another nerve-staple shock. He collapsed, hopeless. As defiant as his proclamation had been, his fighting spirit was crushed—until he heard a scream. He heard a steel door close and lock.

A girl’s strong voice rang, "I'll never surrender! I'll never be broken!"




Elena1030 -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 1:02:27 PM)

Your story reminds me of a sequence of scenes from A Wrinkle in Time. I like what you've done here!


The style of your first draft was too wordy for your subject, especially since you've got a lot to say in only 750 words! The wordiness overshadowed the blunt truth of Captivo's plight. Tighter writing will emphasize the harshness of his experience and the cold, calculating "null-ness" of the society you're depicting.

Your style of using more adjectives, verb phrases with three to five words, and lots of prepositional phrases is fine for other subjects and for longer pieces, I think.

Make sense?

I hope you'll be able to tell the differences between my word choices and yours --- so that you can see how my "tightening philosophy" works when I approach a piece and then begin to work on it. My word choices aren't better b/c they're mine. I'm not here to toot my own horn. [:)] You probably would be able to do the very same sort of editing if the piece were mine. So... I'm hoping that we're coming from similar perspectives on "writing tight." I know that I need it too --- it's just so hard to kill your darlings!!

Blessings as you continue to revise and edit!




IonMoon -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 2:34:18 PM)

Im looking at it at work between... well... work. I have it down to 750ish and will post in a little bit here. I don't think I removed anything germane to the story.

Tara P




IonMoon -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 2:36:37 PM)

One question- should that be the smell of diesel?

Tara




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 2:45:48 PM)

I actually meant the sound of a diesel engine - thanks for noticing. Good call.




IonMoon -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 2:59:38 PM)

Duh! I just re-read your post and see the word count is 750... I am down to 670 and was trying to shave 20 more. [sm=icon_smile_yikes.gif]

Here's what I've got:

"No!" Captivo struggled against the straightjacket. "You can't make me one of you!"

The smell of diesel and the shaking revealed he was not in a room, butsome kind of truck. Two people stood before him, dressed and groomed identically with cropped, white hair. Wires lined their charcoal suits, tiny lights blinking on their collars.

"Refrain from motion, young one." The one to the left.

Captivo searched their faces for signs of age or gender, but could only discern that they were human. Cold, lifeless eyes; small, fragile noses; teeth as white as their hair, twice as shiny. Their slender lips were glossed below recessed cheekbones.

He continued to fight. One of his captors forced his head down, bashing his nose into his knee. A painful sting in the back of his neck accompanied the sound of an air gun behind him. The hand released. A tear streaked down his face as he realized sitting up hurt worse. Was liquid running down his neck? The faces remained expressionless.

"What did you do to me?" he asked in horror.

"You have been nerve-stapled, child. Remain still, or the device will send one-hundred volts down your spine."

He was desperate to escape, but Captivo had afraid to move. The truck rounded a sharp turn and stopped suddenly. Captivo slammed into the wall. It was true. The jerk of his body activated the nerve-staple and a shock ran down his back. By handles on his straightjacket, he was pulled out of the vehicle, but the lingering pain distracted him from his plight. Sunlight assaulted his eyes.

In the distance, a girl screamed as she was pulled from two people. Her parents? Two captors that looked much the same as Captivo's, restrained them.

A massive skyscraper rose before him. The windows were black, harshly contrasting with the blue sky. His captors pulled him forward. He acquiesced. Compliance was less painful.

The lobby was metallic--silver. A sign read: The Family Home: Reeducation Center. Tiny red lights guided them to an elevator--a large portal into a deep, black abyss. The elevator screeched into motion. No floor indicator was visible, so Captivo could only imagine how many floors they were going up. Or down. The thought of going down frightened him even more.

A few moments passed before the doors slid open. Hundreds of brilliant lights poured in, momentarily blinding him. He was forced ahead into a massive gymnasium. Children were playing in groups and in lines and. He was surprised at the silence. No laughter, no speaking, no running about. They merely sat quietly. One line was filing into a side room. No adults led them, they seemed to automatically know to go to the massive doorway at the back of the gymnasium.

Captivo was led through hall after hall, room after room. One room held white dogs, each with a single black spot on its foreheads. Another held artists drawing the same rainbow on the identical canvases. He wanted to protest--to tell them there was so much more. He was powerless.

His trek ended in a small, empty room. He sat alone on the floor by the back wall, staring at his two captors. One almost looked teary-eyed, which allowed slightly feminine characteristics to shine through this guise of generic gender.

"Please help me." He knew that this woman's heart had been touched. There was a soul in there.

"You can't fight it," the woman said as her accomplice closed the gated door. "No one can. I tried, too. No one can."

"You'll be released into The Society once you've undergone the reeducation process." Captivo stood and slammed his shoulders against the door, but it was already locked.

"I'll never surrender! I'll never surrender! My spirit will not be broken!" Motionless, he cried, recovering from another nerve-staple shock. He collapsed on the ground. His actions contradicting his defiant declaration. He heard a scream in the adjoining room as a steel door locked. A girl yelling, “I'll never surrender! I'll never be broken!"




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 3:35:58 PM)

Thanks so much for your edits and suggestions, Elena1030 & rainbowtvp! I will take a look at them and make some revisions, and then post a final draft for you. After that, I'll post the final at my FW page & my new writing.com page.




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 3:53:25 PM)

Question 4 you - why so many paragraphs? It seems excessive to me to have a paragraph break so often, especially after speech. Do you know something that I don't?




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 8:54:02 PM)

Update:

Here's my final draft. I took both of your changes into consideration and added a few of my own. Here it is! Let me know what you think:




"Captivo"
By Michael N Lovdal

Captivo struggled against his straightjacket in desperation. "No!" he screamed, "you can't make me one of you!" The sounds and vibrations told him that he was in some kind of truck. Two people stood before him, dressed and groomed identically, with cropped white hair and charcoal-black suits that were wired throughout. Tiny lights blinked on their collars.
"Refrain from motion, young one," one warned. Captivo searched their faces for signs of gender, but all he could identify was that they were indeed human. Cold and lifeless eyes; noses small and fragile, and teeth white as their hair, and twice as shiny; their slender lips were glossed below recessed cheekbones.
He continued to fight. One captor grabbed him by the hair and forced his head down, bashing his nose into his knee. Captivo felt a painful sting in the back of his neck and heard an air-compressor gun go off behind him. The hand released and he straightened up in pain. A tear streaked down his face; sitting up made his neck hurt even worse. Was liquid streaking down his neck? His captor's faces remained expressionless, apathetic.
"What did you do to me?" he asked in horror.
"You have been nerve-stapled, child. Remain still, or the device will send a hundred volts of electricity down your spine."
He was desperate to escape, but Captivo was terrified of being shocked. The truck stopped suddenly, slamming Captivo into the wall. The sudden jerk of his body activated the nerve-staple and a quick shock ran down his back. Despite the pain, his attention was diverted by being dragged out of the now-parked vehicle.

The harsh sunlight assaulted his eyes as he emerged from the truck, pulled along by handles on his straight-jacket. A girl screamed in the distance as she was pulled from two adults. Her parents? Two captors, dressed akin to Captivo’s restrained them.
He didn't resist as they pulled him into a dark building–compliance was less painful.
The lobby was metallic-silver with glossy-black low-lights. A sign read, "The Family Home; Reeducation Center." Tiny red-tinted lights guided their way as they approached and entered the elevator, an intimidatingly large portal into an even deeper black place. The elevator screeched as it hurled upwards. With no floor indicator, Captivo could only imagine how far they were going up. Or down. Going down frightened him even more. Wait! Yes - they were definitely going down!

The elevator eventually slowed and opened. Brilliant light poured in from the room before him, blinding him for a few moments. He was forced ahead into a massive gymnasium. Children were playing in groups and in lines–but no laughter. Not a single child spoke, nor were any children running about. They merely sat quietly in a circle. Another group seemed to be going to a side room in single file. No adults led them; they just seemed to know where to go.
At the far end of the gymnasium another doorway led them through a series of halls lined with doors. Captivo saw a room with white dogs, a single black spot every forehead. He saw a room of artists, all drawing the same rainbow on the same large-sized canvases. He wanted to protest and scream that there was so much more that they could do with their talents. No chance.

Captivo was led into a small, empty room. He sat down on the floor by the back wall, glaring at his captors. One almost looked teary-eyed. When emotion crossed their face, he saw slightly feminine characteristics shine through the guise of generic gender.
"Please help me," he pleaded, knowing that this woman's heart had been touched. There was a soul in there.
"You can't fight it," she said. "No one can. I tried, but I couldn't. No one can." The other captor slammed the gated door shut. "You'll be released into The Society once you've undergone the reeducation process."
Captivo leapt up to his feet and slammed his shoulders into the door, but it was locked shut.
"I'll never surrender! I'll never surrender! My spirit will not be broken!" He stood crying, recovering from the pain of another nerve-staple shock. He collapsed, hopeless. As defiant as he had been, his fighting spirit was crushed–until he heard a scream from the cell beside him. He heard another door slam and lock.
A girl's strong voice proclaimed, "I'll never surrender! I'll never be broken!"

© 2008 Mike Lovdal.




A few notes on my changes: several of your changes would have involved breaking from the flow and consistency of my writing, so these were adapted with your purpose in mind, while putting aside your exact wording. Some changes were omitted as they removed vital information from the story. For the most part, your suggestions were extremely helpful!

Thank you so much! I ended up 2 words under the limit. Tough call.




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (5/30/2008 9:18:38 PM)

By the way - for anyone who's interested, "Lady Spring" is now available on my Writing.com portfolio!




Elena1030 -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/1/2008 2:19:57 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Locke

Question 4 you - why so many paragraphs? It seems excessive to me to have a paragraph break so often, especially after speech. Do you know something that I don't?


I'm not sure if Crosswalk's setup will allow for indenting paragraphs (it doesn't: I just tried it), so I just did block style, which explains the line of space in between paragraphs. (And your story is kind hard to read without the spaces in between paragraphs....b/c it came out half in block style and half in regular style by the time it appeared inthe thread as a post.)

When the speaker changes, you start a new paragraph. Hence more paragraphs than you're used to.




IonMoon -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/1/2008 2:46:21 PM)

Yeah, about paragraphs: new paragraph for each speaker in dialogue. In general the shorter paragraphs are preferred.

As far as dialogue here are some moe tips: While strong verbs are usually recommended, avoid varying your dialogue tags (stick with said rather than she cried, whispered, complained, etc.) or don't use them at all. You can add action with the speech to identify the speaker.

Tara P




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/2/2008 11:14:45 AM)

Hmm.

For paragraphs, I don't like the amount of space that having a line in between minor paragraphs creates. I understand the need of it for major paragraphs as I used, but mostly to change the scene, and not for minor things. This is also the way I always see it in my literature textbook, so I dunno about that one.

Regarding varying dialogue tags - one of my biggest pet peeves about other authors is their excessive use of "he said / she said." It bores me to no end. There has to be a happy medium somewhere...

Thanks once again for all of your help!




IonMoon -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/2/2008 11:34:39 AM)

Yeah, as Elena said, the spaces here are just meant to be new paragraphs, so in a typical double spaced manuscript, you would not have the extra space, just an indent.

Just keep in mind if your goal is to publish, it isn't as much about what you like as it is what an editor likes. What has been found is that when people read, they ignore certain words- like said. If you add a different tag, it takes the focus away from what the character is saying. Rather than varying the tags, you can just use action to designate who is speaking. You only need a tag at all when it is unclear who said something.

Tara P




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/2/2008 2:22:48 PM)

I'm trying to decide if this is an example a rule that must be followed, or a rule that is followed all too often and I could be a bit of a novelty by breaking. As much as I do want to be published, i'm even more concerned about my writing being the best that it can be, and I don't think that those two positions are always hand-in-hand.




IonMoon -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/2/2008 3:07:34 PM)

quote:

ORIGINAL: Locke
I'm trying to decide if this is an example a rule that must be followed, or a rule that is followed all too often and I could be a bit of a novelty by breaking. As much as I do want to be published, i'm even more concerned about my writing being the best that it can be, and I don't think that those two positions are always hand-in-hand.


Typically authors don't get to break rules for the novelty until they become established in the field...

http://www.pammc.com/dialogue.htm
http://users.wirefire.com/tritt/tip4.html
http://www.writing-world.com/fiction/said.shtml
http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art50939.asp

Remember, you want to keep the readers focused on your story and not let the words get in the way, if that makes sense.

Tara P




Dancre -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/13/2008 10:44:21 PM)

Great story, Locke, as usual. :) Been forever since the role playing days. As for your question, sorry, kiddo, for now you've got to follow the rules set down by the Great and Mighty Gatekeeper. Good Luck and God's blessing on the story. Let us know what happens.

kim




Locke -> RE: Please Help - I need to trim (6/14/2008 6:44:57 PM)

hey Dancre! Yeah, it's been too long!

...

"Got to?" Nobody's got a gun to my head. I ain't got to do nuthin'. [:D] (See my response in "Pet Peeves.")




Page: [1]



Forum Software © ASPPlayground.NET Advanced Edition 2.5 ANSI